IP Litigation Update
Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB) Update: Director Returns Merits-Based Considerations to the PTAB
On November 10, 2026, Director John Squires of the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) issued a memorandum that returns merits-based institution decisions to the Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB) for inter partes review (IPR) and post-grant review (PGR) proceedings.1 The memorandum was co-signed by John Duffy, the USPTO General Counsel and Supervisory Solicitor, and became effective on Monday, November 16, 2026.
The memorandum includes two primary sections. In Section I, the memorandum discusses multiple policies implemented by the USPTO since March 2025, including the decision to consolidate all institution decisions with the Director. In Section II, the memorandum (i) describes the new procedure for institution decisions, (ii) provides guidelines on how the PTAB should analyze merits-based and non-discretionary considerations, and (iii) discusses the application of preliminary injunction legal standards to the institution decision. This update focuses on Section II of the memorandum.
Procedural Changes to Merits-Based Institution Decisions
Since October 17, 2025, the Director has exclusively decided whether to institute IPRs and PGRs. Under the new process, the Director “will continue to review discretionary considerations that do not involve the merits of the challenges to the patents.”2 This means the Director will continue to exclusively evaluate whether an IPR or PGR proceeding should be discretionarily denied in view of non-merits-based factors, such as the status of parallel proceedings, and issue a written decision or summary notice on discretionary denial.3
If an IPR or PGR proceeding is not denied by the Director on discretionary grounds, the proceeding will be referred to a three-member panel of the PTAB to evaluate the merits. The memorandum emphasizes the PTAB will evaluate “merits and non-discretionary considerations.”4 This includes not only whether the IPR or PGR petition satisfies the institution standard (e.g., reasonable likelihood of success for IPRs) but also “discretionary factors related to the merits of the entirety of the challenges raised in the petition.”5 For example, the PTAB may deny institution “if the petitioner fails to make the requisite showing for a substantial majority of the challenged claims” even though, as the memorandum acknowledges, the relevant statutes demand only that the petitioner make the requisite showing for at least one challenged claim.6 The memorandum also provides various considerations for the panel to consider, which are discussed below.
The memorandum explains that the PTAB should issue a decision that “briefly address[es] the merits-based considerations that the panel found important.”7 It emphasizes that the “decision should set forth sufficient information showing that the petitioner has or has not met the appropriate standard at least as to one claim and one ground asserted in the petition but need not address every ground or argument,” and it provides two Director opinions to use as examples.8
According to the memorandum, the panel for evaluating institution will be assigned according to the PTAB’s current panel assignment procedures. To the extent “a PTAB panel institutes review in a case, a different PTAB panel will be assigned to the case ... to conduct the trial,” and the “new panel will not include any judges assigned to the institution decision panel.”9 This is a departure from the PTAB’s prior practice under which the same PTAB panel that instituted review generally also conducted the trial.
With respect to pre-institution briefing, the memorandum does not modify the current pre-institution briefing procedures. This means that parties will continue to file separate discretionary denial briefs when appropriate.10 These new procedures apply to all IPRs and PGRs that have not been referred for a merits-based review.
Guidelines for Merits-Based Review
The memorandum includes five non-limiting guidelines for the PTAB to apply when evaluating whether an IPR or PGR should be instituted. The memorandum explains that these are “illustrative and not exhaustive” and “arise out of the statutory framework outlining a minimum threshold for institution”:
- A proceeding should be denied if it does not “point out how the prior art discloses or renders obvious each limitation of each challenged claim” and “provide an understandable explanation of the element-by-element specifics of the patentability challenges, including an identification of particular portions of prior art on which the petitioner is relying.”11 Pointing to an Examiner’s findings without further explanation is insufficient.
- A proceeding should be denied if it “fails to make the requisite showing for a substantial majority of the challenged claims.”12
- A proceeding should be denied if the Patent Owner’s Preliminary Response “raises a reasonable argument, well-supported with reliable, credible evidence, that the petitioner fails to meet the institution standard for a substantial majority of the challenged claims.”13
- A proceeding should be denied if the three-member panel “determines that a reasonable argument, well-supported with reliable, credible evidence, shows that the petitioner fails to meet the institution standard for a substantial majority of the challenged claims.”14
- When evaluating whether an IPR satisfies the institution burden for a challenged claim, the three-member panel should find that the IPR does not meet the institution burden for a challenged claim “if the arguments for and against unpatentability of a particular challenged claim are both reasonably supported when considering all of the evidence (i.e., the evidence and arguments are in equipoise).”15
Additional Guidelines for Institution Standards
The memorandum provides additional guidance for evaluating institution by referencing certain legal standards. It states that Section 314(a) provides “that the Director may not authorize institution of an IPR unless the Director determines that the information in the petition and any respect thereto shows that there is a ‘reasonable likelihood that the petitioner would prevail with respect to at least one of the claims challenged in the petition.”16 Referencing the legislative history of the Leahy-Smith America Invents Act (AIA), the memorandum explains that former Sen. Jon Kyl of Arizona noted that “courts apply the ‘reasonable likelihood’ standard to adjudicate preliminary injunctions.”17 The memorandum explains that in the context of preliminary injunctions, “the reasonable likelihood standard requires the movant to show that it will likely prove its case in light of the presumptions and burdens that will inhere at trial on the merits” and that if “the party opposing the injunction raises a substantial question concerning validity ... the preliminary injunction should not issue.”18 The memorandum states that these “guidelines set forth examples where a petition does not meet its institution burden.”19
With respect to PGRs, the memorandum explains that the institution standard for PGRs is “more likely than not.”20 Again referencing the legislative history of the AIA, the memorandum quotes statements from Sen. Kyl stating that the “more likely than not” standard is a higher standard than “reasonable likelihood.”21 Besides referencing these statements, the memorandum does not provide additional guidance on the PGR standard.
1 This memorandum follows statements made by the Director during a September 2026 hearing before Senate Judiciary Committee Subcommittee on Intellectual Property. At that hearing, the Director announced his intent to return merit-based institution decisions to the PTAB. See Statement of John Squires (Sept. 29, 2026) at 7, available at https://www.judiciary.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/e5a21495-b7b0-4962-650e-5e18213b112e/2026-09-29-PM_Testimony_Squires_ede844c2-3240-403d-95a7-0686d085cbf0.pdf.
2 Memorandum Returning Merits-Based Considerations to PTAB (Nov. 10, 2026) at 6, available at https://www.uspto.gov/sites/default/files/documents/returning_merits_based_considerations_to_ptab.pdf.
3 Id. at 6, 11-12.
4 Id. at 6, n.1.
5 Id.
6 Id.
7 Id. at 12.
8 Id.
9 Id. at 12.
10 Id. at 7-8 (“The process for briefing discretionary considerations, as outlined in the Interim Processes Memorandum and the Interim Director Discretionary Process webpage, and the process for briefing the merits and non-discretionary considerations will remain the same.”).
11 Id. at 8.
12 Id. at 8-9.
13 Id. at 9.
14 Id.
15 Id.
16 Id. at 9.
17 Id. at 10.
18 Id. at 10-11 (citations and internal quotations omitted).
19 Id. at 11.
20 Id. at 9-10.
21 Id. at 10.
Attorney Advertising—Sidley Austin LLP is a global law firm. Our addresses and contact information can be found at www.sidley.com/en/locations/offices.
Sidley provides this information as a service to clients and other friends for educational purposes only. It should not be construed or relied on as legal advice or to create a lawyer-client relationship. Readers should not act upon this information without seeking advice from professional advisers. Sidley and Sidley Austin refer to Sidley Austin LLP and affiliated partnerships as explained at www.sidley.com/disclaimer.
© Sidley Austin LLP
Contacts
If you have any questions regarding this Sidley Update, please contact the Sidley lawyer with whom you usually work, or

Offices
Capabilities
Suggested News & Insights
- Stay Up To DateSubscribe to Sidley Publications
- Follow Sidley on Social MediaSocial Media Directory

