Skip to main content
Capital Markets Update

Public Company Accounting Oversight Board Proposes to Update the 135-Day Comfort Letter Negative Assurance Rule

The Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (PCAOB) has proposed to replace the fixed 135-day outside date for auditors to give “negative assurance” in comfort letters. Under the PCAOB proposal of November 3, 2026, auditors would be able to issue “negative assurance” as of any date after the issuer’s most recent audited or reviewed period and before the date by which the issuer’s next annual or interim financial statements are required to be filed with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), subject to the discretion of the issuer’s auditors. Because it would be tied to the issuer’s filing deadline, the proposed cutoff for “negative assurance” comfort would adapt to quarterly, semiannual, or other possible reporting cadences. If adopted, the proposed changes would provide issuers with a longer window to access the capital markets without a lapse in customary auditor comfort. 


Background
 
In an offering of securities, it is customary for the underwriters to receive from the issuer’s independent auditor “negative assurance” in a comfort letter on subsequent changes in key balance sheet and income statement items since the last audit or review period. Under PCAOB Auditing Standard 6101, an auditor may give “negative assurance” on subsequent changes only as of a date less than 135 days after the end of the most recent audited or reviewed period. After that date, the comfort letter is limited to describing procedures performed and findings obtained, and underwriters may be unwilling to proceed on that basis. 
 
As a result, there are periods when companies face difficulties in receiving such “negative assurance” and thus accessing capital markets. Under the current quarterly reporting regime, the period between the end of the third quarter and the deadline for the Form 10-K filing can be as long as 182 days for a calendar-year nonaccelerated filer, leading to a 47-day period in the first quarter where “negative assurance” could not be issued. 
This period could increase to as long as 212 days for the proposed small nonaccelerated filer category, and the period between the semiannual period end and the Form 10-K deadline could reach up to 274 days for semiannual filers under the SEC’s proposed semiannual reporting regime. 

The proposed amendments
 
Under the proposal, auditors would be able to issue “negative assurance” as of any date after the issuer’s most recent audited or reviewed period and before the date by which the issuer’s next annual or interim financial statements are required to be filed with the SEC. Negative assurance would remain anchored to the most recent audit or interim review, and the proposal would not expand the auditor’s procedures. Auditors would retain discretion on the issuance of “negative assurance,” including the ability to provide “negative assurance” comfort on certain line items but not others. 
 
A nonexhaustive list of factors that auditors could consider in connection with the issuance of “negative assurance” includes the time since the last audited or reviewed period, management’s ability to respond to inquiries about changes through the requested date (e.g., where that date is not a month-end), effectiveness of internal control over financial reporting, changes in senior management or key personnel, restatements, the company’s ability to continue as a going concern, and the appointment of new auditors during the period. The PCAOB describes these factors as examples that may inform the auditor’s judgment, not as restrictions.

Practical implications
 
Under the proposal, timely filers could launch offerings in windows now constrained by the 135-day rule. Late filers, however, would not be able to obtain subsequent-change “negative assurance” comfort from their auditors as of dates on or after the missed filing deadline, and comfort on those changes would be limited to procedures performed and findings obtained. Because “negative assurance” would remain discretionary, the practical benefit will depend on each audit firm’s approach, particularly for dates well after the last audit or review. Where the auditor declines, underwriters may look to additional due diligence or a chief financial officer certificate to cover the gap.

Conclusion
 
If adopted, the proposal would give issuers considerably more flexibility on offering timing, subject to auditors’ discretion. Public comments on the proposal are due on January 4, 2027. Any final amendments would require SEC approval. The PCAOB is seeking comment on whether the amendments should take effect immediately upon the SEC’s approval or 30 days following the date of such approval. Companies planning 2027 offerings should consider, together with their auditors and underwriters, their comfort letter requirements and consider submitting comments on the proposal. 
 

弁護士広告—Sidley Austin LLP はグローバルな法律事務所です。当事務所の所在地および連絡先情報は、www.sidley.com/en/locations/offices に掲載されています。

Sidley は、本情報をクライアントおよび関係者の皆様へのサービスとして、教育目的のみに提供しています。本情報は、法的助言として解釈または依拠されるべきものではなく、また弁護士と依頼者の関係を生じさせるものでもありません。読者は、専門家の助言を求めることなく本情報に基づいて行動すべきではありません。Sidley および Sidley Austin とは、www.sidley.com/disclaimer に記載のとおり、Sidley Austin LLP およびその関連パートナーシップを指します。

© Sidley Austin LLP