Capital Markets Update
SEC Proposes Fundamental Overhaul of Executive and Director Compensation Disclosure Rules
On November 13, 2026, the Securities and Exchange Commission (Commission or SEC) proposed a fundamental redesign of executive and director compensation disclosure rules under Item 402 of Regulation S-K. The proposal would narrow the number of executives covered from five to two in most circumstances, replace the familiar Summary Compensation Table with two new tables capturing compensation granted and compensation earned, replace the historical equity awards tables with a revised table illustrating the lifecycle of an equity award, and substantially simplify disclosure of perquisites, severance arrangements, pay-versus-performance, pay ratio, clawbacks, and other compensation matters. The Commission describes the objective as more focused, principles-based disclosure of material information with lower compliance costs.
The proposal would change not only the length of compensation disclosures but also the information registrants are required to disclose. It would provide registrants with greater flexibility in how executive and director compensation information is presented.
THE PROPOSAL AT A GLANCE
|
Named executive officers (NEO) |
Primary executive pay tables |
Perquisites |
|
|
|
The Commission estimates average annual compliance-cost savings of approximately $244,000 per registrant, with estimated one-time implementation costs of approximately $82,000 per registrant. Comments are due 60 days after publication in the Federal Register.
Our Take
- A different compensation narrative. The proposed tables distinguish compensation opportunities from amounts ultimately earned. While this presentation may improve clarity, the proposal creates the potential for disclosures of compensation figures that may diverge sharply on a year-over-year basis — especially where equity awards vest or options are exercised long after grant, including after an executive departs from the registrant.
- Regulatory relief may outpace market practice. The proposed disclosure rules would serve as a baseline for required disclosure, and, while many registrants will be pleased with the disclosure relief provided in the proposed rules, investor expectations, say-on-pay engagement, and peer practices will inform how registrants prepare their disclosures following the adoption of the final rules.
- Consider this proposal alongside filer-status reform. The Commission’s separate May 2026 filer-status proposal would expand scaled disclosure to a much larger population of nonaccelerated filers. While the current proposal and the May 2026 proposal are distinct and neither is final, both indicate a Commission desire for registrants to focus on providing material information to investors in a manner that is not overly burdensome or expensive.
What Would Change
Fewer NEOs
Under the proposal, the definition of NEO would cover only individuals serving as a registrant’s PEO or PFO, or acting in a similar capacity, during the last completed fiscal year. This would generally reduce coverage from five executives to two for registrants subject to the full rules and from three executives to two for smaller reporting companies (SRCs) and emerging growth companies (EGCs). Registrants would continue to be required to disclose compensation information for former PEOs and PFOs if they served in such capacity at any point during the last completed fiscal year.
Practical implications:
Because the NEO definition is used well beyond Item 402, narrowing it to the PEO and PFO would affect several other disclosure obligations.
- Form 8-K. The release notes that Items 5.02(b) and (e) are tied to NEOs. Under the proposal, the Form 8-K requirements relating to disclosing new or material amended compensation arrangements would be limited to the PEO and PFO. Further, in the case of departures, registrants would be required to disclose on a Form 8-K only the departure of the PEO, PFO, and the other enumerated positions under Item 5.02(b) (i.e., president, principal accounting officer, principal operating officer, or any person performing similar functions). The relief with respect to a narrower group subject to the Form 8-K rules should be welcomed by registrants, particularly in light of the views of proxy advisory firms regarding disclosure around departing executive officers. If the rules are adopted as proposed, registrants should update 8-K checklists, disclosure controls, and director-and-officer questionnaires and decide whether to keep announcing departures voluntarily, particularly if the departure of a noncovered executive might be deemed material.
- Item 403(b). Individual beneficial ownership reporting would be limited to the PEO, the PFO, and directors. Group reporting for all directors and executive officers would continue.
- Item 404(a). The release states that the change “may reduce the number of situations” in which the exception for compensation reported under Item 402 is available. Registrants would need to reconsider the related person transaction analysis for executive officers outside the PEO and PFO.
- Internal Revenue Code Section 162(m). According to the proposal, Department of the Treasury staff informally advised the Commission that the deduction limit continues to apply to the three highest-paid officers other than the PEO and PFO whether or not their pay is reported. Registrants will still be required to calculate pay for a broader group for purposes of determining Internal Revenue Code Section 162(m) application.
- Golden parachute and clawback disclosure. The two-person NEO limit would apply to disclosures under Item 402(t) and Item 402(w), but the underlying obligations for clawback policy application would not narrow: Rule 10D-1 and the listing standards would still reach all executive officers.
Of course, there is nothing preventing a registrant from voluntarily including disclosure for additional executives. Registrants that want to keep investor-facing disclosure about the broader team have an alternative: They may voluntarily provide full compensation table disclosure for additional executives without making them NEOs for purposes of the Compensation. Discussion and Analysis (CD&A), pay-versus-performance, or the other disclosure requirements listed above. Because the option applies only if the compensation tables are provided in their entirety for each additional executive, registrants should weigh the added disclosure burden against any potential investor and proxy adviser goodwill it may earn.
Three tables would replace the existing executive compensation architecture
The proposed Granted Compensation Table and Earned Compensation Table would replace the Summary Compensation Table, while the proposed Status of Equity Awards Table would track equity awards throughout their lifecycle. Together, these three tables would replace the tabular disclosure that registrants and investors have become accustomed to over the past two decades — namely, the Summary Compensation Table, Grants of Plan-Based Awards Table, Outstanding Equity Awards at Fiscal Year-End Table, Option Exercises and Stock Vested Table, Pension Benefits Table, and Nonqualified Deferred Compensation Table.
|
Proposed table |
Principal purpose |
How it would work |
|
Earned Compensation Table |
Compensation outcome: what was earned in the covered year |
|
|
Granted Compensation Table |
Compensation opportunity: what was granted for the covered year, intended to illustrate total direct compensation |
Certain first-quarter equity grants for prior-year performance could be reported in the prior performance year, if elected by the registrant |
|
Status of Equity Awards Table |
Bridge between equity grants and outcomes |
Award-by-award terms and status, generally in share counts, without annually recomputing hypothetical performance results or market values of outstanding awards |
The proposed Earned Compensation Table and Granted Compensation Table generally would present three fiscal years, or two for SRCs and EGCs. The Commission would permit supplemental columns, tables, footnotes, and narratives where the registrant deems them necessary to explain material information. Large accelerated filers would tag the three tables in Inline XBRL but would no longer be required to apply XBRL tagging to pay-versus-performance or clawback disclosure.
Practical implications:
- “CEO pay” would no longer have a single directly comparable Summary Compensation Table total. We would expect investors and proxy advisory firms to focus on the information contained in the new Total Compensation Earned column under the Earned Compensation Table.
- The Earned Compensation Table would treat cash-based and equity-based awards consistently, reporting each when compensation is earned by the executive (on vesting for stock and on exercise for options) rather than reporting equity at grant as required under the current rules.
- The Granted Compensation Table would use target, as specified in the award agreements, rather than probable performance outcomes for equity awards, resulting in a potential disconnect from the values reported for financial reporting purposes and potentially inflated Total Compensation Granted for equity awards with low probability of payouts at the time of grant (e.g., moonshot awards).
- The Earned Compensation Table would capture equity values when stock vests or options are exercised, potentially resulting in a significant portion of compensation not being reported as earned if the equity award vests or is exercised after the executive ceases to be an NEO.
Perquisites: higher threshold and more discretion
|
CURRENT RULE $10,000 aggregate threshold |
PROPOSED RULE $150,000 aggregate threshold |
|
All potential perquisites must be tracked to test the threshold. |
Optional exclusion for qualifying de minimis fringe benefits; more flexibility in perquisite determinations. |
The aggregate reporting threshold for perquisites would rise from $10,000 to $150,000 per NEO. Registrants could exclude individual benefits that qualify as de minimis fringe benefits under Internal Revenue Code Section 132(a)(4), such as holiday in-kind gifts or occasional theater or sporting event tickets, from the tracking calculation. The requirement to value perquisites using aggregate incremental cost would be eliminated, providing greater flexibility to determine value based on other valuations used by the registrant, such as those used for tax purposes.
The Commission also proposes revising — not abandoning — its two-part perquisite analysis. Under the first part of the analysis, a registrant would be able to reasonably determine in good faith that a benefit is integrally and directly related to an executive’s duties, with the Commission proposing to rescind its prior categorical examples of items that it considered to be perquisites, including security provided at a personal residence or during personal travel. Security services or company aircraft used for security reasons would not automatically be excluded; treatment would depend on the facts and a reasonable, good-faith determination. The proposed perquisite guidance would also eliminate the current guidance with respect to the two-part analysis that provides that registrants should ignore whether a benefit is provided for business reasons or the convenience of the registrant. Both of these changes provide much greater flexibility and deference to registrants in determining whether an item is a perquisite.
Practical implications:
- The revisions to the perquisite analysis would provide much-desired relief and clarity, which would allow registrants to tailor their compensation programs to the needs of the registrant and the executive, including with respect to concerns regarding safety of the executive team — without having to make difficult tradeoffs due to disclosure concerns.
- Registrants should revisit the perquisites that they provide, not with a view of changing them but instead to understand and reassess the business rationale for the perquisites.
- The potential perquisite disclosure relief will not change the need for proper board and/or committee oversight, and registrants should continue to maintain robust internal controls to document perquisites provided to the executive team.
A shorter, more principles-based CD&A
For registrants required to provide CD&A, the proposal would replace seven specified topics and 15 illustrative topics currently included in the CD&A requirements with three: (i) compensation program objectives in relation to corporate strategy; (ii) material compensation elements and how amounts are determined; and (iii) if applicable, whether and how the most recent say-on-pay vote affected compensation policies or decisions. With the narrower topics to be addressed, the objective is to provide more principles-based disclosure and eliminate the boilerplate disclosure that has become prevalent in many CD&As. While registrants will be able to leverage portions of their existing disclosure to address the new CD&A requirements, the proposed requirement to tie the compensation program objectives to corporate strategy is a new requirement that was not expressly contained in the prior CD&A requirements. Although many registrants included disclosure in their CD&As linking their compensation programs to broader corporate strategy, particularly in response to investor feedback, registrants will need to ensure that their compensation disclosure is responsive to the new CD&A requirements and the registrant’s broader disclosures with respect to corporate strategy.
Practical implications:
- Similar to how registrants approach the preparation of their disclosure today, the new CD&A requirements will require coordination among legal, human resources, and investor relations departments.
- Registrants should begin discussions with their board of directors regarding the new CD&A requirements and, in particular, evaluate how the material elements of their compensation programs are tied to broader corporate strategy.
- Registrants should continue to confirm that the materials prepared for their board and compensation committees support both the existing CD&A requirements and plan for the expected requirements under the proposed rules.
- When changing corporate strategy or the compensation program, boards and compensation committees will need to be mindful of the effect on each other.
Regulation G reconciliations
Currently, the CD&A instructions provide that disclosure of target levels that are non–generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP) financial measures will not be subject to Regulation G, but disclosure must be provided as to how the target is calculated from the registrant’s financial statements. This instruction allowed registrants to narratively, rather than numerically, explain how the target was derived from the financial statements. Consistent with its general focus on Regulation G compliance, under the proposed rules, any non-GAAP target level or company-selected performance measure that is based on historical financial results must include a quantitative reconciliation of the differences between the non-GAAP financial measure and the most directly comparable GAAP financial measure. In addition, the proposed rules would require that when disclosing a target level or company-selected financial performance measure that is a non-GAAP financial measure, the disclosure must also include an explanation of the reason(s) that the registrant believes the non-GAAP financial measure is more appropriate than a GAAP financial measure.
Practical implications:
- While many registrants already include numerical reconciliations for the target disclosure, this will be a change for some, particularly with respect to the requirement to explain why the non-GAAP financial measure is more appropriate than a GAAP financial measure.
- This disclosure will require cross-functional coordination among legal, accounting, investor relations, and human resources departments.
Dodd-Frank–related disclosure would be streamlined
- Pay-versus-performance. The complex Compensation Actually Paid calculation currently required would be replaced by Total Compensation Earned from the Earned Compensation Table; required performance disclosure would focus on cumulative total shareholder return rather than the current requirements to also include net income, peer group total shareholder return, and a company-selected measure; the coverage period would be reduced from five years to three years; disclosure would focus only on the PEO and PFO; and the requirement to disclose three to seven financial measures that link compensation to performance would be eliminated.
- Pay ratio. The median employee population would be limited to U.S.-based full-time employees (excluding seasonal and temporary workers); median employee identification would generally move from every three years to every five years; and compensation would be determined using the same methodology used for the new Granted Compensation Table.
- Clawbacks. Certain recovery-related narrative and cover-page checkboxes would be eliminated, but the substantive recovery obligations imposed by Exchange Act Rule 10D-1 and applicable listing standards would remain.
Other changes, including director pay and registration statements
The proposal would replace hypothetical quantitative termination/change-in-control payout disclosure with a material-terms narrative and would allow for the omission of disclosure if the registrant properly disclosed this information under Item 5.02 of Form 8-K, simplify golden-parachute table disclosure, and make director compensation disclosure more principles-based without a prescribed table. It would eliminate the Item 402(s) compensation-risk disclosure and the Item 402(x) disclosure regarding equity grants near the release of material nonpublic information.
In welcome relief for issuers that struggle with the desire to file registration statements shortly after the end of the year but prior to the completion of their executive compensation disclosures, the proposed form instructions for Forms S-1, S-4, S-11, 10, and N-2 generally would permit omission of the most recently completed fiscal year’s Item 402 information until the earlier of its disclosure in an Exchange Act filing or 120 days after year-end. A pre-effective amendment would be required if effectiveness occurs after the relevant deadline.
Interaction With the Filer-Status Proposal
The separate May 2026 filer-status proposal would generally extend SRC/EGC-style scaled disclosure accommodations to nonaccelerated filers, potentially covering approximately 81% of current registrants. If both proposals were adopted substantially as proposed, the full CD&A and certain other requirements would apply to a smaller group of larger issuers. The precise interaction depends on the final form of both rulemakings. See Sidley’s May 26, 2026, Update on the proposed filer-status framework.
Timing
The Commission proposes an effective date of the next January 1 following the year in which final rules are adopted and published in the Federal Register. Mandatory compliance generally would begin with the first full fiscal year ending on or after that effective date. Early compliance would be permitted after effectiveness if an amended item is followed in full. This means that if the final rules are adopted and published in the Federal Register in 2027, then the effective date would be January 1, 2028, and mandatory compliance for a calendar-year registrant would begin with respect to the 2028 compensation year (i.e., the 2029 proxy statement), although registrants would have the option to comply with respect to the 2027 compensation year (i.e., the 2028 proxy statement).
While disclosure for the upcoming proxy season will continue to follow the current disclosure rules, boards, compensation committees, and disclosure teams may wish to evaluate where the new granted-versus-earned presentation would materially change their compensation narrative; consider whether investor and proxy-adviser expectations would support retaining selected voluntary disclosures; review the treatment and documentation of perquisites, including executive security arrangements; and identify operational dependencies involving Form 8-K, Internal Revenue Code Section 162(m) compliance, and pay-ratio data. Interested registrants may also consider submitting comments or sharing concerns with the SEC.
Sidley will continue to monitor the rulemaking and is available to discuss its implications and comment-letter strategy.
Attorney Advertising—Sidley Austin LLP is a global law firm. Our addresses and contact information can be found at www.sidley.com/en/locations/offices.
Sidley provides this information as a service to clients and other friends for educational purposes only. It should not be construed or relied on as legal advice or to create a lawyer-client relationship. Readers should not act upon this information without seeking advice from professional advisers. Sidley and Sidley Austin refer to Sidley Austin LLP and affiliated partnerships as explained at www.sidley.com/disclaimer.
© Sidley Austin LLP
Contacts
If you have any questions regarding this Sidley Update, please contact the Sidley lawyer with whom you usually work, or
Offices
Capabilities
Suggested News & Insights
- Stay Up To DateSubscribe to Sidley Publications
- Follow Sidley on Social MediaSocial Media Directory








